We think so. Although we accept that interviewing investment managers might not be everyone’s idea of an exciting afternoon.
But when the conversation is about who looks after your money, how they make decisions and what they do when markets become uncomfortable, it becomes rather more interesting.
That is precisely what we are doing at NBL: taking a fresh look at the investment management expertise available to our clients.
LOOKING FOR A SPARK OF CONVICTION IN A SEA OF SAMENESS
We’re looking for the manager who makes us sit up and listen.
Someone who can put the polished pitch aside and tell us what they think.
Why this investment? Where could it go wrong? Why should our clients own it?
We want clear thinking, conviction and the confidence to be challenged.
The people who bring investment management to life tend to give us much more to think about than those who simply know all the right phrases.
A GOOD REPUTATION GETS YOU A MEETING…
THEN COMES THE QUESTIONS.
Credentials tell us where someone has been. Behaviour tells us far more about who they are.
We want to meet the people behind the presentation.
Who does the difficult research? Who questions a comfortable consensus? Who owns a mistake when it would be easier to blame the market?
Dedication shows in the detail: the preparation, the willingness to answer an awkward question and the effort to revisit a decision when the evidence changes.
We are looking for people who care deeply about their work and remember whose money is at stake.
People whose commitment holds when results disappoint and the questions get harder.
That is when character counts. And that is what we want to understand.
A STRONG RETURN IS INTERESTING.
HOW IT WAS ACHIEVED MATTERS MORE.
A good year can flatter a bad process.
Two portfolios can produce the same return, yet one may have exposed your money to far greater risks. The headline number won’t tell you that.
We want to know what sits beneath it. Was success driven by sound judgement, a handful of concentrated bets or a rising market? What happens when conditions turn? And does the manager recognise where their approach could fail?
Costs deserve the same scrutiny. Every pound charged needs to earn its place. Clear explanations and access to the people making decisions matter too, especially when those decisions are under pressure.
Ultimately, your portfolio has a job to do:
help fund your retirement, support your family or build your future wealth.
That is the measure that matters most.
IF WE ARE CONFIDENT IN OUR CURRENT MANAGERS, WHY LOOK ELSEWHERE?
Because familiarity can soften scrutiny.
And your money deserves better than comfortable assumptions.
We have to challenge ourselves as rigorously as we challenge the managers.
Have we become too comfortable with familiar faces?
Does a good working relationship make an awkward question harder to ask?
Have we examined the detail closely enough, or accepted an answer because we trust the person giving it?
The hardest question is perhaps the most revealing: if we were choosing today, with no existing relationships, would we choose the same team?
We remain confident in our current managers. But that confidence must stand up to fresh examination. Your money is too important for familiarity to become the deciding factor.
Our meetings with other teams give us a valuable opportunity to test our judgement. We have encountered impressive people and capabilities that deserve serious consideration.
The review remains ongoing, and any recommendation must rest on a clear case for our clients.
INTERESTING CONVERSATIONS.
NO DECISIONS YET
The review is ongoing. No decision has been made about changes to our investment management arrangements.
Any future recommendation would need a clear case: what could improve, what it would cost and why it would be appropriate for the clients concerned. Sometimes a thorough review confirms that the existing approach remains the right one. That is a valuable conclusion too.
YOUR MONEY DESERVES OUR CURIOSITY…
AND OUR SCRUTINY.
There is nothing you need to do following this bulletin. We wanted you to know about the work taking place on your behalf.
If the review leads to a recommendation relevant to your investments, we will explain it clearly, including the reasons, potential benefits and costs.
For now, we will keep meeting the teams, asking the questions and examining the answers.
You do not have to find investment management fascinating. You should be able to trust that we take a close interest in it.
Van Greaves
NBL Financial Management Ltd
This bulletin is for general information and does not constitute a personal investment recommendation. Investment values and income can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you invested. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future results.




